Try It Free For 30 Days

Cultured Butter

I got a cheese making kit in the mail a few weeks ago, which I was so excited to rifle through and examine. I love getting new tools and materials for projects.  It’s the same feeling as getting a new, clean notebook for the start of school.  Everything came so neatly labeled and organized.  I never would have known how to go about ordering the various culturing elements and implements on my own.  But, now I’m all set with all the cultures, rennet, cheesecloth, measuring spoons (going as tiny as 1/64th tsp!), a cheese press etc.  Time to get culturing!

Unfortunately, the sweet cow at the farm where we get our milk was busy having a baby and couldn’t be bothered to be making extra milk, despite my shiny new cheesemaking kit!  So, we waited patiently and drank our almond or coconut milk, which was a nice change anyway.  But, we were excited to hear that she finally had her calf and we could finally get fresh, local, raw, delicious milk again!

I started with butter.  The milk from that mama cow was so rich; there was a ton of cream on top.  Do you like my makeshift siphon?  I still haven’t figured out the easiest way to get the cream off the top. Any tips?

We allowed the raw cream to culture naturally by adding a couple tablespoons of cultured dairy, like plain yogurt or buttermilk. It sits out at room temperature for a day, two max, after which we put it in the refrigerator to stop the culturing process, for about 5 hours. We then poured the cream into a mixer and turned it on high, reducing the speed as the butter formed. It was seriously miraculous to watch the butter fat and buttermilk separate in the mixer.  My husband and I stood over it Oohing and Aahing like it was the 4th of July.  I will just never tire of the magic of kitchen alchemy.

Like kneading bread, pressing and washing the butter had a meditative quality to it.  There are certain things that can’t be rushed, but simply ask you to slow down and enjoy the process.  Making butter is one of those things, not time consuming, but just something that asks you to be present.

And the result?  Oh, mercy!  It’s cultured.  It’s creamy.  It’s flecked with local, ancient salt.  And I put it on everything I can get away with.  We feel like kings eating something this delicious.  Clay is talking about making me a butter mold, something a little better than this tart pan.  How fun would that be?

    Print Recipe

    Cultured Butter

    • 1 gallon raw milk
    • 2 Tbsp cultured dairy yogurt, buttermilk, &c.


    1. Separate cream and add cultured dairy. Let sit at room temperature for 12-48 hours.
    2. Refrigerate for 5 hours.
    3. Mix on high, without splattering the cream, and increase speed as it thickens. Reduce speed as clumps of butter form to allow them to stick to each other.
    4. Remove butter from buttermilk, rinse and press until water runs clear.
    5. Salt if desired.
    6. Store in the freezer or fridge, as the butter spoils within a few days at room temperature.

    Powered by
    Plan To Eat


  Leave a Reply

  • I use a turkey baster.

    nicolle May 7, 2013 AT 10:15 am
  • Yes, I was also wondering if you used.a blender or a food processor. I have used a food processor once or twice in the past. I have never tried cultured butter before. Does it taste stronger? i bought raw milk butter once (it cost a fortune, but I bought it for the novelty) and it had a strong flavor that no one but myself enjoyed. I wonder if this is the same idea.

    Linda M May 7, 2013 AT 9:42 am
  • Another way to separate the cream is to simply pour the milk into a wide shallow container, let the cream rise and skim it off with a spoon. The fat separator suggestion reminds me of the old canister separators that were a tall can on legs with a spigot on the bottom and vertical window on the side. The milk was drawn off from the bottom and the window allowed you to see the level of the cream as you poured off the milk. I looked for a picture but couldn’t find one.

    Judy May 5, 2013 AT 8:17 am
  • What did you use to mix the cream? A blender, food processor, etc? Thank you!

    Michelle Z May 5, 2013 AT 8:02 am
  • I love making butter. :-) I use my blender.
    I use a turkey baster to suck my cream off the top…but I ordered a drink dispenser to try it this way because it looks SO EASY!

    Stacy @Stacy Makes Cents May 5, 2013 AT 5:41 am
  • Have you tried using a fat separator? I have this thingie that you pour the grease into after roasting a chicken or turkey. The fat floats to the top, but the spout connects at the bottom. Then you pour off the “not fat” stuff, leaving only the fat in the cup. :) I have no idea if it would work, but hey, worth a try!

    RevAllyson May 4, 2013 AT 5:15 pm

Black Friday Weekend Sale50% all Yearly Subscriptions More Info
Starts in:
<%= days_left %>





Plan to Eat is an online menu planner that uses your recipes, scheduled for the days you want them. It automatically makes your grocery list, organized the way you like to shop, using the recipes you’ve selected. Plan to Eat makes it easier to eat real food, prepared at home, with your family gathered around your own table.

We'd love for you to give it a try. Sample it free for 30 Days!

You are invited to a free, 30 day, full-service, no strings attached trial.

No payment information is required and your feedback is welcome.

At the end of the trial you can subscribe for $4.95/month or $39/year.


Try it Free For 30 Days

Gift Subscriptions

Eat healthier food. Save time & Money. Know what‘s for dinner.

Wow, that sounds like a great gift!